Historical Social Research / Historische Sozialforschung 34 (2009), 2

Historical Social Research/ Historische Sozialforschung
HSR Vol. 34 (2009) No. 2 – Special Issue: Counterfactual Thinking

Special Issue:
Roland Wenzlhuemer (Ed.):
Counterfactual Thinking as a Scientific Method / Kontrafaktisches Denken als wissenschaftliche Methode.
& Mixed Issue (Articles, Cliometrics); 376 pages.

Counterfactual thinking is a common occurrence in everyday-life situations. What if I had bought a ticket before boarding the bus? What if I had not gone to the rock concert and never met my partner? On first glance such counterfactual thoughts appear to be nothing more than a sentimental and all too human trait. What practical use is there in thinking about alternatives of the past that have never been realized? It is, therefore, no surprise that counterfactual thinking in a scientific context has for a long time been eyed suspiciously. Can it have any analytical value to systematically think about things that have never happened and surely will never happen? While some academic disciplines such as law, economics or philosophy have answered this question in the affirmative and have employed counterfactuals as a matter of course, others – such as history or political science – have been particularly critical of the practice that has often been perceived as void of any methodological validity or analytical value.

In the last two decades, however, psychological research has demonstrated that counterfactual thinking in everyday life is more than a sentimental pastime and has clearly discernable analytical uses for the thinker. This volume brings together contributions from a variety of different disciplines and seeks to illustrate how counterfactual thinking can, indeed, be useful from a scientific perspective. It builds on the results of recent psychological research and the experiences that researchers in disciplines such as law or economics have made with counterfactual thinking. The volume ultimately seeks to highlight the common analytical ground between counterfactual thinking in everyday life and in academic contexts – particularly in the field of historical research.

Allen Abonnentinnen und Abonnenten von H-Soz-u-Kult bieten wir die neu erschienene HSR-Ausgabe Vol. 34 (2009) No. 2 zu einem Sonderpreis von € 12,- (gegen Rechnung; Preis inkl. Versand) an.

Rückfragen und Bestellungen richten Sie bitte an: zhsfgesis.org
Sandra Schulz
GESIS
HSR Redaktion
Liliencronstr. 6
50931 Köln
Fon +49 / 221 / 476 94 - 96
Fax +49 / 221 / 476 94 - 55

Links zur HSR:
www.gesis.org/hsr/
www.ssoar.info/index.php?id=145
www.hsr-retro.de/

CONTENTS

SPECIAL ISSUE
Roland Wenzlhuemer (Ed.):
Counterfactual Thinking as a Scientific Method / Kotrafaktisches Denken als wissenschaftliche Methode..

INTRODUCTION

Roland Wenzlhuemer
Editorial: Unpredictability, Contingency and Counterfactuals. 9

Neal J. Roese & Mike Morrison
The Psychology of Counterfactual Thinking. 16

Roland Wenzlhuemer
Counterfactual Thinking as a Scientific Method. 27

COUNTERFACTUAL HISTORY

Richard Ned Lebow
Counterfactuals, History and Fiction. 57

Georg Schmid
Counterfactuals and Futures Histories. Retrospective Imagining as an Auxiliary for the Scenarios of Expectance. 74

Ann Talbot
Chance and Necessity in History: E.H. Carr and Leon Trotsky Compared. 88

COUNTERFACTUALS IN OTHER DISCIPLINES

Geoffrey Winthrop-Young
Fallacies and Thresholds: Notes on the Early Evolution of Alternate History. 99

Helmut Weber
The ‘But For’ Test and Other Devices – The Role of Hypothetical Events in the Law. 118

Jens Ennen
The Evaluation of Welfare State Performance: Modelling a Counterfactual World. 129

Ekaterina Svetlova
“Do I See What the Market Does Not See?”: Counterfactual Thinking in Financial Markets. 147

CASE STUDIES IN COUNTERFACTUAL HISTORY

Juliane Schiel
Crossing Paths between East and West. The Use of Counterfactual Thinking for the Concept of “Entangled Histories”. 161

Elke Ohnacker
“What If ... Charlemagne’s Other Sons had survived?” Charlemagne’s Sons and the Problems of Royal Succession. 184

Sören Philipps
The Birth of the European Union: Challenging the Myth of the Civilian Power Narrative. 203

Tobias Winnerling
Invented Formosa, the Empire of the Great Khan and Lilliput: Can 18th Century Fiction be Counterfactual? 215

--------------------------------

MIXED ISSUE

ARTICLES

Rainer Diaz-Bone
Konvention, Organisation und Institution. Der institutionentheoretische Beitrag der „Économie des conventions“. 235

Bernt Schnettler & Jürgen Raab
Interpretative Visual Analysis Developments: State of the Art and Pending Problems. 65

Ralf Bohnsack
The Interpretation of Pictures and the Documentary Method. 296

Annette Vowinckel
Past Futures: From Re-enactment to the Simulation of History in Computer Games. 322

CLIOMETRICS

Carlo Ciccarelli & Stefano Fenoaltea
Shipbuilding in Italy, 1861-1913: The Burden of the Evidence. 333